AccueilAccueil  ­PortailPortail  ­FAQFAQ  ­RechercherRechercher  ­S'enregistrerS'enregistrer  ­BOUTIQUE zitocland   .BOUTIQUE zitocland .  ­ConnexionConnexion  ­ContactContact  
Poster un nouveau sujet   Répondre au sujetPartager | 
 

 DefNat Francaise

Voir le sujet précédent Voir le sujet suivant Aller en bas 
Aller à la page : 1, 2  Suivant
AuteurMessage
Harri
CHEVALIER
CHEVALIER


Masculin
Age: 49
Localisation: PORI, FINLAND
Thème: Legion Etrangere
Date d'inscription: 26/02/2008
Nombre de messages: 274

MessageSujet: DefNat Francaise   Ven 24 Oct - 0:29

Bonjour everybody,
I am just courious to know about the clasps (agrafes) of French Medaille Defence National.
If a soldier qualifies for this medal, will the first clasp be the branch of service (Genie, Infanterie, Troupes, Aeroportées etc.) or which one is the first?
How does he get the next clasps like geographical ones?
When he gets one of upper class, can he change the clasps from the previous bronze medal to the new one?
How many clasps are allowed to wear at the same time? May a soldier have earned more clasps than he is allowed to wear?

Cordialement, Harri
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Le Crabe-Tambour
GRAND CROIX
GRAND CROIX


Masculin
Age: 25
Localisation: FRANCE
Thème: ODM et diplômes militaires de la France et de ses alliés, de 1852 à nos jours ; promos EOGN.
Date d'inscription: 13/10/2006
Nombre de messages: 1159

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Ven 24 Oct - 0:40

Hello Harri,

Every degree of this medal can be awarded with 1 clasp (speciality only) or 2 clasps (speciality + geographical), and we can wear the clasps of the lower degrees within the limits of 3.

Best regards,

Laurent.

_________________
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Harri
CHEVALIER
CHEVALIER


Masculin
Age: 49
Localisation: PORI, FINLAND
Thème: Legion Etrangere
Date d'inscription: 26/02/2008
Nombre de messages: 274

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Ven 24 Oct - 21:34

Bonjour and Thank you Laurent for most informing answer. Very Happy

Best Regards, Harri
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Chris Boonzaier
Décoré de la Médaille de l'Ordre
Décoré de la Médaille de l'Ordre


Masculin
Age: 40
Localisation: Allemagne
Date d'inscription: 13/02/2007
Nombre de messages: 163

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Ven 21 Nov - 2:59

Hi

Why does 3eme REI qualify for the Infantry bar, but 2eme REI does not?

It is a question I have always wondered about....

Thanks
Chris
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Harri
CHEVALIER
CHEVALIER


Masculin
Age: 49
Localisation: PORI, FINLAND
Thème: Legion Etrangere
Date d'inscription: 26/02/2008
Nombre de messages: 274

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Dim 23 Nov - 16:47

Hi Cris and the rest of the group....
That really is a good point that I even hadn't noticed hein6 . So, which clasp 2REI qualifys for?
2 REP gualifys for PARACHUTISTE and 1&2 REG for GENIE ???? What about 1REC, DMLE and 13DBLE ?

Cordialement, coucou2 Harri
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
LCD
COMMANDEUR
COMMANDEUR


Masculin
Age: 59
Localisation: 17
Thème: ARTI et le reste
Date d'inscription: 17/04/2008
Nombre de messages: 726

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Dim 23 Nov - 16:59

Good afternoon HARI,

Your questions are really pertinent, it would be necessary to have the right handbook on the desk to answer without any mistakes !!!
In fact, you may receive this medal because :
- you collected the right number of point needed for it, and so you put on the ribon the clasp of speciality
- you are really performant somewhere or for an authority, so you may receive it with a geographical clasp or function (eg : "Ministre de la Defense" means this minister attributed you the medal)
- You are very very very performant and in this case you may receive the golden medal with Palm or Stars like for "Croix de Guerre" .

Your's

LCD
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Harri
CHEVALIER
CHEVALIER


Masculin
Age: 49
Localisation: PORI, FINLAND
Thème: Legion Etrangere
Date d'inscription: 26/02/2008
Nombre de messages: 274

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Lun 24 Nov - 12:06

Bonjour a tous Laughing ,
and thanks to LDC for clarifying the award system.
There's still one question "eating" me. Is it possible to get 3 clasps at the same time like for example LEGION ETRANGERE, TROUPES AEROPORTEES and MISSIONS D'ASSISTANCE EXTERIOURE in a bronze medal?
Looking at Crabe-Tambour's comment above, I wonder when and how the clasp mentioned last was awarded, meaning separately later or all three at the same time Question.

Cordialement, Harri.
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
LCD
COMMANDEUR
COMMANDEUR


Masculin
Age: 59
Localisation: 17
Thème: ARTI et le reste
Date d'inscription: 17/04/2008
Nombre de messages: 726

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Lun 24 Nov - 12:15

Hy HARRI,

For me your proposal is quite realistic . That would mean the soldier is enlisted at the 2° REP and received his "Def-Nat" after having been in an operation overseas.

You're wright .

Your's

LCD
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Le Crabe-Tambour
GRAND CROIX
GRAND CROIX


Masculin
Age: 25
Localisation: FRANCE
Thème: ODM et diplômes militaires de la France et de ses alliés, de 1852 à nos jours ; promos EOGN.
Date d'inscription: 13/10/2006
Nombre de messages: 1159

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Lun 24 Nov - 12:26

Hi Harri,

No, it's normally impossible : the decree of 1982 changed in 2004 allows only to award at the same time one single speciality bar (here "LÉGION ÉTRANGÈRE" or "TROUPES AÉROPORTÉES"), or one speciality bar and one geographical bar (here "MISSIONS D'ASSISTANCE EXTÉRIEURE"). To wear two speciality bars, it's therefore necessary to have the silver medal at least.

Best regards,

Laurent.

_________________
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Harri
CHEVALIER
CHEVALIER


Masculin
Age: 49
Localisation: PORI, FINLAND
Thème: Legion Etrangere
Date d'inscription: 26/02/2008
Nombre de messages: 274

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Lun 24 Nov - 12:43

Hi again and,
thanks again for LCD and Crabe-Tambour for clarification. There seems to be an situation practice against rules as I have two sets of medas of a former legionnaire that I know personally (caporal in 2e REP in 1987-92) and in both sets there are these mentioned three clasps in bronze DefNat.

Cordialement, Harri.
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Chris Boonzaier
Décoré de la Médaille de l'Ordre
Décoré de la Médaille de l'Ordre


Masculin
Age: 40
Localisation: Allemagne
Date d'inscription: 13/02/2007
Nombre de messages: 163

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Mar 25 Nov - 19:50

In 1989-94 ALL REP members had 3 bars... with Bronze medals. A very small portion had 2 bars (LE and TAP)

Guys from 3eme REI got it with infantry bar and LE, 2eme REI guys got it with LE.

A Caporal Chef once told me it was because 2eme RAI was no longer "Infantry" but Motorised Infantry.

Best
Chris
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Harri
CHEVALIER
CHEVALIER


Masculin
Age: 49
Localisation: PORI, FINLAND
Thème: Legion Etrangere
Date d'inscription: 26/02/2008
Nombre de messages: 274

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Mar 25 Nov - 20:18

Hi again and thanks to Chris for great help.
Could you please clarify just one more thing. Were the three clasps you mentioned awarded at the same time or the Assistance..... later to be added to the ribbon?

Yours, Harri tchin1
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Chris Boonzaier
Décoré de la Médaille de l'Ordre
Décoré de la Médaille de l'Ordre


Masculin
Age: 40
Localisation: Allemagne
Date d'inscription: 13/02/2007
Nombre de messages: 163

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Mar 25 Nov - 21:10

HI,

mine was awarded with LE and Missions bars. I think 2 is the maximum that fit onto the line on the certificate.

Maybe the REP guys just automatically added a TAP bar?

I am not sure.

Best
Chris
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Harri
CHEVALIER
CHEVALIER


Masculin
Age: 49
Localisation: PORI, FINLAND
Thème: Legion Etrangere
Date d'inscription: 26/02/2008
Nombre de messages: 274

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Mar 25 Nov - 21:34

Hello everybody,
and thaks to Chris for clarifying this matter.

Yours, Harri Very Happy
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
Jean-Phy
GRAND MAITRE DE L'ORDRE
GRAND MAITRE DE L'ORDRE


Masculin
Age: 41
Localisation: Quelque part en France
Thème: décos 2éme guerre et au petit bonheur la chance
Pseudo Ebay: jean-phybrocantes
Date d'inscription: 21/12/2006
Nombre de messages: 3120

MessageSujet: Re: DefNat Francaise   Lun 15 Déc - 17:12

Hi Harri,

You can see a example of Def' Nat' diploma with bar attribution :

http://www.forum-insignes-medailles.net/vos-diplomes-vieux-papiers-f29/un-ptit-gars-du-2-rep-t15006.htm

regards

Jean-Phy
Revenir en haut Aller en bas
 

DefNat Francaise

Voir le sujet précédent Voir le sujet suivant Revenir en haut 
Page 1 sur 2Aller à la page : 1, 2  Suivant

Permission de ce forum:Vous ne pouvez pas répondre aux sujets dans ce forum
FORUM INSIGNES & MEDAILLES :: --------- FORUM IN ENGLISH --------- FORUM EN ANGLAIS ------- :: Medals of the world-
Poster un nouveau sujet   Répondre au sujet